Is love on the small screen better than the real thing? Brynn's happy ending has gone up in flames. She's newly divorced and living with a roommate - Josh - to afford her mortgage. At least she's got Carson's Cove to binge - her beloved 90s teenage soap. So when a birthday cake shows up on her and Josh's doorstep, Brynn makes a wish for her own happily-ever-after. The next morning, she doesn't wake up in her apartment. She's in Carson's Cove... and Josh is there too. Except they're not Brynn and Josh; they're the sweetheart and the bad boy. Will they stick to the script, or will real love change the story forever?